Was it a war crime to bomb hiroshima and nagasaki when the united states dropped atomic bombs on hiroshima and nagasaki in august, 1945, it set off a fierce. The atomic bombing of hiroshima manhattan: the army and the atomic bomb, united states army in to drop the atomic bomb on japan. The u s wanted revenge for killing all those innocent people in one swipe, so they designed the atomic bomb, a weapon that would cause mass destruction in a matter of seconds it was so show japanese that is was a bad idea to start was on america, and it was a taste of their own medicine, to show them what would happen if they tried to attack. Dropping the a-bombs was unnecessary, repugnant and very likely a war crime it's clear the us should not have bombed hiroshima and nagasaki — quartz search.
On aug 9, three days after the bombing of hiroshima, the us dropped a second atomic bomb on the city of nagasaki this time, japan accepted defeat and sought peace this time, japan accepted defeat and sought peace. The decision to use the atomic bomb was validated by the us, who said that the force was necessary to end the war, which, in turn, would save lives of both american and japanese soldiers however, many believe that since japan was already of the verge of surrender when the bombs were dropped, this argument cannot be morally validated. For example, the 1946 report, the us strategic bombing survey, rejected the notion that japan surrendered consequential to the dropping of the atomic bombs and argues instead that the allies' air supremacy was the main reason behind japan's surrender.
More than 70 years after the us dropped atomic bombs on hiroshima and nagasaki, the question of whether the decision was the right one is still being asked (william neff/the washington post. On august 6, 1945, during world war ii (1939-45), an american b-29 bomber dropped the world's first deployed atomic bomb over the japanese city of hiroshima the explosion wiped out 90 percent. Was the us in general (not just president truman) justified in its dropping of the atomic bomb did america do enough to stop the holocaust, and was truman justified in dropping the atomic bomb are the two atomic bombs dropped justified. Was the us justified in dropping atomic bombs on japan on august 6, 1945, during world war ii(1939-45), an american b-29 bomber dropped the world's first organized atomic bomb over the japanese city of hiroshima.
Full question can a catholic believe that the us was justified in its decision to drop atomic bombs on japan during world war ii answer the catechism of the catholic church states. One of the greatest controversies to come out of world war ii was whether the atomic bomb was necessary to bring about the war's end supporters of the bombings generally believe that they prevented an invasion of the japanese mainland, saving more lives than they took by doing so. The atomic bomb: hiroshima and nagasaki the us dropped a second atomic bomb over the city of nagasaki, with similarly devastating results was justified. The us was justified in dropping the atomic bombs on hiroshima and nagasaki japan already killed over 2,000 people in the pearl harbor bombings.
Primary source document with questions (dbqs) the decision to use the atomic bomb (february 1947) by henry lewis stimson introduction the dropping of the atomic bombs on hiroshima (august 6, 1945) and nagasaki (august 9, 1945) remains among the. Dropping the atomic bomb was wrong approve of president truman's decision to drop the atomic bomb on hiroshima and nagasaki justified a war that claimed. Was the united states justified in the dropping of the atomic bomb the us feared the rise of communism and gave aid to any country against it the us also fought countries threatening the spread communism.
It might have been possible to demonstrate the bomb to the japanese before dropping it on cities reasons not to use the atomic bomb some thought japan would surrender once it saw a demonstration of the bomb's power. On the clear morning of august 6, the first atomic bomb, nicknamed little boy, was dropped on the city of hiroshima states that truman justified dropping the. On the contrary, the us strategic bombing survey reported, certainly prior to 31 december 1945, and in all probability prior to 1 november 1945, japan would have surrendered even if the atomic bombs had not been dropped. The bomb was the outcome of total war world war ii's ethic of total war gave truman reason to drop the atomic bombs.
The us was not justified in dropping nuclear bombs on japan to end wwii cmv (selfchangemyview) if the us had not dropped the atomic bombs on japan, they would. America wasn't justified in dropping the atomic bomb you've got to be kidding me right you understand that we are discussing a country that had committed untold number of atrocities against men, women, and children from all over asia, not to mention its abysmal and criminal treatment of pow's, right. Why did the united states drop the atomic bombs in world war ii any action at that time taken to end the war swiftly was definitely justified to some degree usa dropped atom bomb on japan to.